Confessions of a non-directing screenwriter
Monday, May 4th, 2009After some umming and aaaing I decided to pull out of Project Microbudget Feature. As the project outgrew its original microbudget mode, two things happened: the finance fell through, and the ideas got bigger, meaning that we now had 0% of something medium-sized, rather than 100% of something tiny. Although between us we have a decent amount of industry experience, we were all new to our roles, which would have made funding very difficult. I did come up with a few ideas which I genuinely believe could have given the fundraising a huge boost, but in order to try those avenues we would have had to have made the whole journey to get the story to a decent draft.
The problem with the script was that D and I were both working on it, but not together. We started to meet on a weekly basis in a pub in Cardiff. I loved those meetings; there’s always something magical in seeing ideas bounce around the place like that. I really liked D’s sense of story too, but the further into development we got, the more clear it became to me that we were trying to write two different stories. And while some of my ideas were complete and utter horse manure, I believe some were very good. To see those good ones go straight out the window made me think that perhaps we were not on the same wavelength. Of course, him being the director, it would end up more his film than mine anyway (especially as he had such a big part in developing the story), so I just thought that the best thing for me would be to nip it in the bud. I told them I was more than happy for them to carry on with it, but I would go off and write my story, as a novel.
My decision years ago to focus on screenwriting rather than being a writer/director was based on the fact that I find it hard enough to master writing, let alone directing too. But who in their right mind would want to be a non-directing screenwriter? Anyone who’s read Adventures in the Screen Trade will know just how difficult life is even for a famous screenwriter with two Oscars to his name. And what about Alan Ball? He wrote one of history’s great screenplays, got an Oscar for it, and then had to go back to TV because he couldn’t get arrested! Just about every Hollywood screenwriter out there is dreaming of being a novelist apparently. [And if that’s the case, do robotic screenwriters like Blake Snyder dream of electronic novels?! Sorry - I digress ;-)]
And if that’s what it’s like at the top, then what is there to aspire to? Especially when you consider that what will end up on the screen will not be your story anyway. The only positive thing I can think of at the moment is something Robert McKee said. He said that when directors, actors, producers and others fiddle with a writer’s script, it’s usually for the best. And that’s coming from a screenwriting guy. I suppose the reality is, if you want to write movies and you don’t want to direct them, then just write the damn thing and move on to the next one. Grow up and lose your ego.
If D & P decide to pursue the project and drive it in the direction that D wanted to take, I wish them all the best, and I know that their talents will make it something special.